Derby Winner Seeks Another Jewel of Triple Crown
Special to OddsShark from Michael Dempsey
The odds of I’ll Have Another having another jewel of the Triple Crown by Saturday are good, but his chances at completing horse racing’s trifecta are slim.
We’re talking about Kentucky Derby winner I’ll Have Another as he prepares for Saturday’s Preakness Stakes at Pimlico in Baltimore. Eleven 3-year-olds will line up in the $1 million sprint, and the one with a shot at giving the sport its first Triple Crown winner since 1978 isn’t even favored.
While the colt was draped in roses, Derby runner-up Bodemeister received nearly as much attention for his outstanding effort. He set sharp early fractions and held on gamely in the loss, and all indications are the Bob Baffert trainee is going to be the betting favorite Saturday.
Bodemeister is currently 2-1 odds, while I’ll Have Another is 5-2, according to the Preakness odds list at Odds Shark.

They boast an edge over the remainder of the field, but both figure to be well backed at the betting windows. Since the name of the game is making money on Saturday, let’s take a look at the remainder of the field and give each as much of a positive spin as we can:
Cozzetti: The colt skipped the Kentucky Derby after a fourth-place finish in the Arkansas Derby, beaten 9 ¾ lengths by the winner, Bodemeister. He makes his third start since January, and his speed figures are improving. His trainer, Dale Romans, saddled Shackelford, last year’s Preakness winner. Odds: 30-1
Creative Cause: After his win in the San Felipe back in March, in which Bodemeister was second, this colt looked like he could end up the Derby betting favorite. He came up a head short of I’ll Have Another in the Santa Anita Derby and was sent off as just less than 12-1 on Derby Day. The colt was caught in tight quarters on the first turn and had to come eight wide coming out of the far turn. He was still beaten just three lengths for all of it. He is flying under the radar and will likely offer us some betting value. Odds: 6-1
Daddy Nose Best: The Steve Asmussen trainee did not have the best of trips in his 10th-place finish in the Derby. The colt had to steady when forced in during the early stages of the race, made a good middle move and was bumped around in the stretch and faded. The colt came into the race off wins in the El Camino Real and Sunland Derby, and his victory at Sunland Park produced one of the few triple-digit Beyer speed figures we saw along this year’s Derby trail. Odds: 15-1
Optimizer: The colt as sent off at 42-1 in the Derby, and he did not have the best of trips. The colt stalked the early pace while saving ground early, angled to the outside for the stretch drive but had to steady in traffic, went back down toward the inside but did not have much punch left late. His best effort this spring came in his runner-up finish to Secret Circle in the Rebel at Oaklawn Park. It does not hurt to have trainer D. Wayne Lukas, who has won this race five times (most recently in 1999 with Charismatic), in his corner. Odds: 30-1
Pretension: The Chris Grove trainee has the advantage of some home cooking as he is based at nearby Bowie and has a win over the main track. The colt won the Canonero II on May 5. The colt has landed in the exacta in six of his eight starts, missing only in his two starts in Grade 3 company, a fifth-place finish in the Gotham at Aqueduct behind Hansen and a ninth-place finish in the Illinois. Back in 2002, there was a hopeless local long shot named Magic Weisner who came rolling down the Pimlico stretch to come up just three-quarters of a length short of the top spot at 45-1. Could there be more magic on Saturday for a local? Odds: 30-1
Teeth of the Dog: This colt is the most lightly raced among all of the Preakness contenders this year, with just four starts under his belt and just one against winners. The colt broke his maiden at Gulfstream Park in his third career start and then jumped up to face much tougher competition in the Wood Memorial at Aqueduct. He gave a good account of himself in a third-place finish. The two that beat him were Gemologist and Alpha, who did not fire their best in the Derby, but this guy still appears to have a ton of upside. He is trained by Michael Matz, the 2006 Kentucky Derby-winning trainer, whose Barbaro was pulled up in the Preakness with an injury. Odds: 15-1
Tiger Walk: This colt is coming off a fourth-place finish in the Wood, where he made a mild late run, beaten five lengths for the top spot and 1 ¾ lengths behind Teeth of the Dog for third. He has outrun his odds in his last two starts, sent off at 17-1 in the Wood and at 31-1 in a fourth-place finish in the Gotham in his previous outing. The colt is coming off a career top speed figure and looks to be improving. If he gets some pace to run at, he could be a factor in the stretch at a generous price. Odds: 20-1
Went the Day Well: Owned and trained by last year’s Derby winning connections, the colt came into the Derby off a win in the Spiral at Turfway Park, but he was dismissed at 30-1 on Derby Day. The colt was bumped coming out of the gate, outrun in the early going, came with a seven-wide run and was picking up horses in the stretch. He was beaten just 2 ½ lengths for the top spot. The colt will not be as far back on Saturday, and his trainer, Graham Motion, has won plenty of races at Pimlico over the years. This colt may be the biggest threat to the two top betting choices. Odds: 6-1
Zetterholm: This New York-bred has three wins in his five career starts, all coming against state-breds. His stakes debut came last out in his victory in the Patsyprosepect at Aqueduct. He is stepping into much deeper waters here outside of the New York-bred ranks, but he does have trainer Rick Dutrow in his corner. Dutrow won the Derby and Preakness in 2008 with Big Brown, and the barn has been red hot, winning at a 31 percent clip overall in 2012. Odds: 30-1
Michael Dempsey provides his full card report for the Preakness Stakes as well as for Belmont Park and Churchill Downs each racing day. Mike’s full card report includes his selections, analysis, fair odds line, and wagering recommendations. Mike’s Best Plays Report is available each weekend, with his strongest plays and selections including the top stakes races.


