Originally written on Fangraphs  |  Last updated 11/20/14

One of the most often cited criticisms of WAR is that replacement level is essentially an arbitrary construct, making the entire model just an act of theoretical speculation. The idea of replacement level is to essentially set a baseline for expected performance from a team that invested the absolute minimum in putting together a Major League roster. This replacement level team wouldn’t have a farm system, so that they didn’t have to spend money on draft picks, coaches, equipment, or facilities. They would rely entirely on league minimum veterans to build out their roster, thus allowing us to see how approximately many wins a team could expect if they did the absolute bare minimum in terms of organizational investment. That team doesn’t exist, obviously, as even organizations that completely tear down their big league roster work to rebuild through accumulation of young talent, and no team actually spends the league minimum on its Major League payroll. Thus, the criticism that the entire exercise is a thought experiment, not applicable to the Major Leagues and incapable of serving as a baseline against which Major League players should be judged. However, that argument misses out on the fact that MLB teams give us a pretty great list of replacement level players every winter, thanks to the processes of minor league free agency and the waiver system. Minor League free agents are the quintessential idea of a replacement level player. For the most part, they simply want a job in the big leagues, and they don’t have enough leverage to be picky about what kind of job it is. They take non-guaranteed invites to spring training in hopes of earning a spot on the roster, and if they don’t play well in March, they end up in the PCL or the International League, waiting for an injury to create a need that will get them back to the big leagues for a little while. If a Major League team was attempting to build out a roster of league minimum players, these are exactly the kinds of talents they’d be picking from. However, they could also supplement those players with waiver claims, as there is a second pool of replacement level talents available to any team willing to simply use a 40 man roster spot to obtain a player who doesn’t have a say in where he lands. This winter, we saw a number of players — Scott Cousins, Russ Canzler, and Sandy Rosario among the most notable — change teams multiple times, as GMs tried to sneak them through waivers so they could be stashed in Triple-A without requiring a spot on the 40 man roster. Since they wouldn’t require more than a league minimum salary and the price of a waiver claim is so low that it doesn’t materially affect a team’s budget, we’ll include these players in the pool of replacement level talents as well. Using the Transaction Tracker from MLBTradeRumors, I went through and identified two dozen position players who signed minor league contracts or were repeatedly claimed on waivers this winter, with the sole requirement being that they had at least 100 combined plate appearances between the last two seasons. Okay, I actually only identified 23 such players, but Jeremy Hermida had 93 plate appearances, and two dozen sounds better, so I included him in order to get the list up to 24. Since I did this manually, I’m sure there are a few guys I missed, but as you’ll see, it’s not going to change the conclusion in any meaningful way – these 24 guys a pretty good representative sample of what a replacement level Major Leaguer looks like. To combat selection bias, we don’t want to just focus on what these players did last year, as the fact that we’re identifying players who were forced to sign minor league deals means that we’re starting with a group that likely underachieved last year. A replacement level player who overperformed in 2012 likely secured his place on a 40 man roster for the winter, removing him from the pool of players available to sign minor league deals or get passed through waivers. So, we need to adjust for the fact that the 2012 performances are likely a bit below their actual talent levels, and we can simply adjust by looking at a larger pool of data. We don’t want to go back too far, of course, as many of these guys are aging players who aren’t what they used to be, so to try and come up with a balance of a larger but still relevant sample, we’ll simply focus on how these 24 players did over the last two years. The results? Season PA BB% K% ISO BABIP AVG OBP SLG wOBA wRC+ Fld BsR WAR Total 10,459 6.8% 20.7% 0.131 0.275 0.233 0.289 0.365 0.288 78 (103.4) (11.9) (0.7) In the past two years, these 24 players have combined for over 10,000 plate appearances in the Major Leagues, and they’ve combined for -0.7 WAR. If you scale that back to a rate of per 600 plate appearances, that’s -0.04 WAR per full season. For a “theoretical” construct that supposed doesn’t reflect reality, replacement level seems to do okay. For those interested, here’s a list of the 24 players, and their 2011-2012 performance. If someone asks you what a replacement level player looks like, point to one of these guys. Name PA BB% K% ISO BABIP AVG OBP SLG wOBA wRC+ Fld BsR WAR Matt Downs 413 6.1% 20.6% 0.207 0.265 0.241 0.303 0.448 0.327 106 (7.0) (2.0) 0.8 Ryan Sweeney 518 8.7% 17.6% 0.092 0.323 0.263 0.328 0.355 0.302 87 1.6 (2.3) 0.8 Shelley Duncan 511 9.2% 22.5% 0.204 0.257 0.231 0.305 0.435 0.321 104 (6.1) 0.4 0.8 Jason Bourgeois 318 4.4% 8.8% 0.063 0.314 0.287 0.318 0.350 0.297 85 (1.8) 3.0 0.7 Jeremy Hermida 93 10.8% 35.5% 0.159 0.319 0.207 0.301 0.366 0.294 88 4.3 (0.2) 0.6 Brent Lillibridge 425 6.6% 31.3% 0.162 0.297 0.226 0.295 0.388 0.301 85 (5.6) 5.0 0.5 Miguel Olivo 830 3.3% 27.1% 0.162 0.268 0.223 0.248 0.385 0.273 74 (10.6) (3.4) 0.4 Austin Kearns 349 11.5% 26.4% 0.104 0.302 0.222 0.334 0.327 0.303 89 (0.6) (0.3) 0.4 Darnell McDonald 278 9.4% 18.7% 0.159 0.250 0.224 0.301 0.384 0.302 83 2.3 (0.5) 0.3 Chris Snyder 377 13.3% 24.7% 0.129 0.253 0.205 0.320 0.334 0.294 84 (6.3) (4.9) 0.3 Jordan Schafer 698 9.2% 25.2% 0.078 0.306 0.226 0.303 0.304 0.274 69 (6.2) 5.2 0.3 Eli Whiteside 250 7.6% 25.2% 0.112 0.244 0.192 0.261 0.304 0.249 56 (0.6) 0.1 0.1 Cesar Izturis 206 2.4% 11.2% 0.087 0.257 0.235 0.254 0.321 0.251 52 3.4 (0.9) 0.1 Juan Rivera 860 7.1% 12.9% 0.127 0.266 0.252 0.306 0.379 0.300 89 (5.9) (3.9) (0.1) Russ Canzler 102 4.9% 22.5% 0.125 0.324 0.271 0.304 0.396 0.301 91 (2.3) 0.3 (0.1) Don Kelly 408 6.9% 13.2% 0.114 0.246 0.227 0.286 0.341 0.280 71 (0.8) 0.4 (0.2) Ryan Raburn 640 5.3% 26.1% 0.144 0.287 0.226 0.272 0.370 0.281 71 (4.4) 2.0 (0.3) Yuniesky Betancourt 812 3.1% 10.8% 0.141 0.250 0.245 0.266 0.387 0.281 73 (15.0) (0.4) (0.4) Ben Francisco 500 9.2% 18.2% 0.131 0.280 0.242 0.317 0.373 0.306 91 (9.4) (1.6) (0.4) Scott Cousins 150 6.7% 30.0% 0.094 0.209 0.152 0.209 0.246 0.199 17 3.9 0.1 (0.6) Danny Valencia 769 5.6% 18.2% 0.131 0.264 0.234 0.274 0.365 0.279 72 (8.0) (4.0) (0.6) Jeff Baker 413 5.1% 22.8% 0.126 0.316 0.254 0.291 0.380 0.292 78 (6.9) (1.0) (0.7) Bill Hall 213 7.5% 32.9% 0.113 0.311 0.211 0.277 0.325 0.266 65 (11.4) (1.5) (1.4) Joe Mather 326 6.1% 21.2% 0.110 0.251 0.210 0.260 0.320 0.253 52 (10.2) (1.6) (2.0)

MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Report: Kings, Nets talking Deron Williams trade

Is Rampage Jackson heading back to the UFC?

WATCH: DeSean Jackson mocks Eagles after win

Michael Vick: Jameis Winston is the future of the NFL

Report: No NFL team is moving to Los Angeles in 2015

Report: 49ers looking for young, offensive mind as next coach

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Sheldon Richardson: I'm on the same level as JJ Watt

Kendrick Perkins: Rajon Rondo wanted out of Boston

Report: Jim Harbaugh being encouraged to take Michigan job

Three quarterbacks who could be traded this offseason

Wolves trade Corey Brewer to the Rockets

Yankees trade Prado to Marlins for Eovaldi in 5-player deal

WATCH: Utah runs trick play on first offensive play of game

Mick Cronin misses game with unruptured aneurism

Steve Alford: Kentucky is best team I've coached against

Peyton Siva jokes that Rick Pitino is in the mob

WATCH: Montrezl Harrell ejected for throwing punch

UNC wearing Jordan-era throwback uniforms

Brian Kelly: Justin Brent gets 'distracted,' is in my doghouse

Five free agent signings that should happen in 2015

Reporter asks Rajon Rondo awkward question about trade

Video: Swaggy P elbows Steven Adams in throat, gets ejected

Video: Grizzlies buy car for assistant who had his stolen

Video: LeBron takes pass to the face from Dion Waiters

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

Kings, Nets talking Deron Williams trade

WATCH: DeSean mocks Eagles

Vick: Winston is the future of the NFL

No NFL team in LA next season?

UNC rocking Jordan-era throwbacks

Reporter asks Rondo awkward question

Three quarterbacks who could be traded this offseason

Jon Lester and the Cubs

Report: NFL players used 'horny juice'

Top 10 worst NBA related commercials of all-time

Phelps gets probation for DUI

NFL coaches on hot seat in Week 16

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.